Saturday, May 22, 2004

Mo' Media Attention - Mo' Miles or Low Miles?

First, let me repeat a key point. I, Pete Blackshaw, am a passionate believer in hybrid technology. But I'm equally passionate about truth in advertising. This blog has shifted from high-octave "love letter" to dispirited "tough critic" because I fear there's a troubling and well-documented gap between the brand "promise" -- reflected in Hybrid advertising, promotion, and dealer representations -- and the actual product "benefit" and performance. Nothing will kill this industry faster than consumer cynicism, especially in the internet age of high-velocity word-of-mouth. With gas prices skyrocketing and a flood of new hybrid vehicles about to enter the market, three things need to happen. (1) Dealers need to work much harder to disclose the "true" mileage to potential buyers, (2) the EPA needs to retool its MPG mileage calculation immediately, and (3) manufacturers need to put in place smart and thoughtful "recovery" programs for early buyers and enthusiasts who feel betrayed and misled by the "mileage" misrepresentations. Meanwhile, more media coverage on this issue continues to roll-out, from Wired News, to Motor Trend, to CBS Marketwatch.

5 Comments:

At 5:44 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Skyrocketing is an understatement. Filled up last night - 84.9p/l ($5.79 per US gallon). Two weeks ago it was 81.9 pence.

I'm expecting it to hit a $1/l by the end of the year.

1 US Gallon = 3.785 litres
£1 = $1.80

 
At 5:45 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Typo, that should've been £1/l

 
At 4:04 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

There is already a disclaimer that says "your mileage may vary".

I think Pete is getting the poor mileage he is for two reasons:

1. Short trips-too short for the Civic's mild hybrid system to kick in-so for the most of the time he was basically driving a standard Civic, and getting mileage to match.
2. He picked the Civic. The Civic gets the worst mileage of the four hybrid cars for sale in the US (old Prius (2000-2003), new Prius (2004+), Insight, Civic). It's a mild system, unlike the two Prius models. Also, of the four, it's the only one where they stuck a hybrid engine in an existing car, instead of building the car around the engine.

Had he bought either Prius (probably the Insight too), and/or had he drove it on longer trips, he probably would have gotten much better mileage.

Basically, Pete needs to realize that "your mileage may vary" means "your mileage may vary". Most people who buy hybrids (espically the ones other than the Civic) get very close to thier EPA ratings, and many people who drive on longer trips (in city or on the highway) get close to the EPA rating even in the city. This blog is causing FUD (fear, uncertainty, and doubt) that the hybrids don't get the mileage claimed, when the vast majority get the mileage claimed, or within the same amount that a non-hybrid vehicle would get (if a non hybrid vehicle claimed 25 MPG but really got 22.5 MPG for a certain driver/commute, a hybrid vehilce which claimed 50 MPG may get 45 MPG). Pete just happens to be unlucky that his driving habits or commute length or whatever cause him to be in the 5% or so that fail to meet these standards.

I'm curious as to what mileage he got in previous vehicles with the same commute/driving habits. How close was the actual mileage to what the EPA claimed in his previous vehicle?

 
At 1:35 PM, Blogger David Ogden said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm really enjoying business

I have a best generation lead opportunity business site/blog. It pretty much covers best generation lead opportunity business related stuff.

 
At 1:41 PM, Blogger David Ogden said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm really enjoying business

I have a home business lead surveyed site/blog. It pretty much covers home business lead surveyed related stuff.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home